Located in the Underground Music Venue, you’ll find an NPC surrounded by pussy (cats). True to her title, she’s the one and only Fisch Crazy Cat Lady, who asks riddles and expects fish as the answers. My guide tells you how to complete all three of her quests, including where to find the fish she requires, and increase mutation chances for specific types.

Start playing Fisch via Roblox. For more on this questline, check out our guide on the Nico’s Yarncaster Rod.

Fisch Crazy Cat Lady Riddles Answers

Warning! This section contains spoilers. Read at your own risk.

Kitten Kerfuffle Part 1

  • First Riddle: In a glassbound night where starlight weaves, a galaxy swims beneath black seas.
    • Required Fish: Shiny Celestial Koi
  • Second Riddle: Intricate patterns light the abyss below, reflections of art, bathed in a cerulean glow.
    • Required Fish: Electric Void Angler
  • Third Riddle: Within Poseidon’s storm, the void grows electric, weaving death’s beauty through the darkest depths.
    • Required Fish: Shiny Flying Fish
  • Fourth Riddle: Winged through sunlight, halos crown its fleeting flight, an angel skimming waves, dancing with the light.
    • Required Fish: Abyssal Coral Emperor
  • Fifth Riddle: An emperor among coral, it reigns with abyssal might, teeth and fins of terror, sovereign of the light.
    • Required Fish: Atlantean Mosaic Swimmer

Part 1 Reward

  • Sacred Cat: Lantern

Kitten Kerfuffle Part 2

  • First Riddle: In the quiet deep, a soft lunar glow plays, dancing on gills that map the night’s hidden maze.
    • Required Fish: Lunar Midnight Axolotl
  • Second Riddle: In the shadowed altar, a frozen shadow glides, gentle in darkness, swift when angered tides.
    • Required Fish: Frozen Umbral Shark
  • Third Riddle: In twilight’s hush, their ashen glow unveils, hidden paths in ruins where mystery prevails.
    • Required Fish: Ashen Fortune Twilight Glowfish
  • Fourth Riddle: With a carrot on its beak, it moves with grace, rainbow scales shimmering in this quiet place.
    • Required Fish: Carrot Prismatic Parrotfish
  • Fifth Riddle: In pastel hues where soft light gleams, whiskers drift through iridescent dreams.
    • Required Fish: Shiny Mosaic Opalescent Catfish

Part 2 Reward

  • Nico’s Yarncaster: Fishing Rod

Kitten Kerfuffle Part 3

  • First Riddle: In the dark depths, its glowing eyes ignite, a colossal shadow slipping through the secret night.
    • Required Fish: Ancient Depth Serpent
  • Second Riddle: Hexed and serpent-like, it drifts below, a silent herald where ocean currents flow.
    • Required Fish: Hexed Oarfish
  • Third Riddle: Frost-wrought blaze beneath mirrored skies, colours dissolve where skrunkly stillness flies.
    • Required Fish: Skrunkly Aurora Trout
  • Fourth Riddle: A fleeting anomaly hops through the deep, leaping in rhythm where the quiet waters sleep.
    • Required Fish: Anomalous Rabbitfish
  • Fifth Riddle: Marks like constellations adorn its regal crest, calming the waters where the deep rests best.
    • Required Fish: Celestial Deep Crownfish

Part 3 Reward

  • Clownfish Cat Toy: Bobber
  • Nico’s Meowfia: Title

Increasing Mutation Encounters

  • Shiny
    • Blessed Enchant: 5% chance
    • Glittered Enchant: 3% chance
    • Shiny Surge: +3% chance
    • Destiny Rod: 10% chance
    • Axe of Rhoads: 5% chance
    • Polaris Serenade: 3% chance
    • Chrysalis: 20% chance
    • Natural Odds/Appraisal: 1% chance
  • Electric
    • Storming Enchant at a 50% chance during Rain.
    • Fished naturally at 0.47% chance (15% chance in the Grand Reef)
  • Abyssal
    • Rod of the Depths: 30% chance
    • Abyssal Spectre Rod: 25% chance
    • Abyssal Enchant: 10% chance
  • Atlantean
    • Trident Rod: 30% chance
  • Lunar
    • Astral Rod: 5% chance
    • Event Horizon Rod: 5% chance
    • Moonlight Mirage: 0.63% chance
  • Frozen
    • Arctic Rod: 100% chance
    • Summit Rod: 40% chance
    • Natural Odds/Appraisal: 0.32% chance
  • Ashen Fortune
    • Volcanic Rod: 25% chance
    • Magma Rod: 10% chance
  • Carrot
    • Carrot Rod: 5% chance
    • Carrot Pools: 5% chance
  • Mosaic
    • Natural Odds/Appraisal: 0.36% chance
  • Hexed
    • No-Life Rod: 50% chance
    • Original No-Life Rod: 20% chance
    • Natural Odds/Appraisal: 0.47% chance
  • Skrunkly
    • Nico’s Yarncaster: 30% chance
  • Anomalous
    • Amonaloud Enchant: 20% chance
  • Celestial
    • Celestial Rod: 100% chance
    • Heavenly Sparkles (Admin Event): 5% chance

It seems you’ve stumbled upon my bio! I’m Sho, your local weeb. Off the clock I am typically watching anime, reading manga, or doing art. I think it’s safe to say that all my unpaid thoughts revolve around anime… That said, watch One Piece! (Or don’t, I’m just a biography.)